Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Concerned Celtiberian's avatar

Thanks, this is another fascinating topic.

IMO Dr Wood made all the right questions but also gave the all the wrong answers. As you have pointed out, the power (not energy, but energy per unit of time) required to blast the twin towers to dust would have required that the DEW would had to be fed by (my own guesstimate) the equivalent of several nuclear power plants. Not feasible. Even less feasible is the scenario that the DEW is fired from orbit. This is basic physics stuff, science highschoolers should have no problem understanding this.

But please note that the “conventional explosives hypothesis” is also not very plausible. It has been calculated that in order to bring down the towers with termite or similars, hundreds of tonnes of explosives would be required. Not only this, you would also need to fix the thousands of individual demolition charges in the precise spots touching the building structure, especially in the core columns, AND you would also need to wire everything, using tens of thousands of meters of cable. Without anyone noticing. If you know a bit about electrical or plumbing/HVAC jobs in large buildings, you will understand how complicated it would have been to disguise it.

And regarding the Caracas operation, it is worth mentioning that all “DEW” weapons, whether lasers, microwave, other electromagnetic etc., do have to be fired quite close to the target, usually hundreds of meters, a couple kms at most. That means, the Venezuelan air defense system was first disconnected, and then were those other weapons used. What’s interesting here for me is that the Gringo Evil Empire chose to use these weapons instead of just blowing up a lot of stuff as is it’s Standard Operating Procedure.

Tom Welsh's avatar

'Such “incapacitator” DEW weapons, often called “heat rays”, fires a 95GHz millimeter-wave beam and penetrates human skin just enough to hit pain receptors'.

Remarkably like the "pain induction" box into which Paul Atreides has to thrust his hand in "Dune". His sensations are described in horrid detail: he seems to feel the skin charring and blackening, yet when he is finally allowed to withdraw his hand it is perfectly normal.

Frank Herbert did work with government in Washington DC in the late 1950s. He was also interested in electronics, as witness his novels "The Dragon in the Sea" and "Destination: Void". It seems possible that he learned about the technical possibility of such weapons, which don't sound terribly complicated.

131 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?